Killers Among Us Bar and Snack Menu | Killers Among Us Printable Add-On

Bring your murder mystery game night to life with a sinister spread of themed drinks and snacks. Every bite and sip is crafted to keep your guests immersed in the world of suspense, deception, and intrigue while playing Killers Among Us.

Mystery Snacks & Killer Bites

Crispy Chip & Dip – A crowd favorite featuring tortilla chips with guacamole (avocado, lime, onion, tomato, cilantro), salsa (mild or medium), queso cheese dip, and creamy sour cream.

Clue Carrots & Crudité – Fresh veggie sticks with a flavorful dip for a lighter bite between accusations.

Poisoned Popcorn – Sweet kettle corn drizzled with dark chocolate and eerie red candy melts, sprinkled with edible glitter for a deadly shine.

Consigliere Caprese Skewers – Bite-sized cherry tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil drizzled with balsamic on skewers — a classy appetizer with a secret agenda.

Serial Killer Cheesecake Bites – Chilled mini cheesecake cups with berry swirl topping, graham crust, and rich cream cheese filling… dangerously delicious.

Themed Cocktails & Mocktails

Nightfall Elixir – A deep, dark berry drink made with blackberry juice, club soda, grenadine, and garnished with fresh blackberries and an orange wedge.

Silent Witness – A refreshing mocktail of apple juice, club soda, mint syrup, garnished with thin apple slices and mint leaves.

Mafia Mist – A foggy, mysterious cocktail of ginger ale and lime juice, with a drop of black food coloring and lime garnish.

Perfect for Mystery Game Nights

Pair these deviously delicious snacks and drinks with your Killers Among Us printable murder mystery game to create an unforgettable evening of secrets, strategy, and suspense. Guests will love how every menu item ties into the theme — making accusations and uncovering killers has never been tastier!